Mechanism of Water Augmentation During IR Laser Ablation of Dental Enamel
Background and Objectives: The mechanism of water augmentation during IR laser ablation of dental hard tissues is controversial and poorly understood. The in- fluence of an optically thick applied water layer on the laser ablation of enamel was investigated at wavelengths in which water is a primary absorber and the magnitude of absorption varies markedly. Study Design/Materials and Methods: Q-switched and free running Er: YSGG (2.79 m m) and Er:YAG (2.94 m m), free running Ho:YAG and 9.6 m m TEA CO 2 laser systems were used to produce linear incisions in dental enamel with and without water. Synchrotron-radiation IR spectro- microscopy with the Advanced Light Source at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory was used to determine the chemical changes across the laser ablation profiles with a spatial resolution of 10- mm.
Results: The addition of water increased the rate of abla- tion and produced a more desirable surface morphology during enamel ablation with all the erbium systems. More- over, ablation was markedly more efficient for Q-switched (0.15 microsecond) versus free-running (150 microsecond) erbium laser pulses with the added water layer. Although the addition of a thick water layer reduced the rate of ablation during CO 2 laser ablation, the addition of the water removed undesirable deposits of non-apatite mine- ral phases from the crater surface. IR spectromicroscopy indicates that the chemical composition of the crater walls deviates markedly from that of hydroxyapatite after Er:YAG and CO 2 laser irradiation without added water. New mineral phases were resolved that have not been previously observed using conventional IR spectroscopy. There was extensive peripheral damage after irradiation with the Ho:YAG laser with and without added water without effective ablation of enamel.
Conclusions: We postulate that condensed mineral phases from the plume are deposited along the crater walls after repetitive laser pulses and such non-apatitic phases interfere with subsequent laser pulses during IR laser irradiation reducing the rate and efficiency of abla- tion. The ablative recoil associated with the displacement and vaporization of the applied water layer removes such loosely adherent phases maintaining efficient abla- tion during multiple pulse irradiation. Lasers Surg. Med.
Key words: erbium laser; CO 2 laser;
dental laser tips; laser ablation; infrared spectromicroscop.
INTRODUCTION It has been well established that extensive water ap- plication is necessary for the efficient ablation of dental hard tissues with Er:YAG and Er:YSGG laser irradiation. The mechanism of interaction between the water-layer, the laser radiation, and the hard tissues is not clearly understood and is somewhat controversial. Early mechani- stic studies focused on tissue dehydration [1– 4]. However, water absorption and diffusion studies in enamel indicate that only approximately half of the water is actually diffusible [5] and the rate for water diffusion is quite slow, on the order of several hours to days. Thermal analysis studies indicate that the tissue has to be heated to tem- peratures exceeding 200– 300 8 C before the diffusible water is removed [6]. Higher temperatures of up to 800 8 C are required to remove the more tightly bound water [6]. Therefore, it is unlikely that simple dehydration by dif- fusion has a significant effect during laser irradiation. Other more novel hypotheses include cavitation bubbles, accelerated water droplets, and apatite crystalline frag- ments. One proposed mechanism dubbed the ‘‘hydrokinetic effect’’ suggests that water droplets are rapidly accelerated into the enamel by absorption in the laser beam [7,8]. Altshluler et al. [9,10] have proposed that solid particles of ablated material are accelerated against the walls of the crater resulting in a polishing effect that removes debris and any protruding sharp edges. In the same study, the authors found that the ablation of enamel could be effectively enhanced by a factor of four via ablation with a quartz or sapphire contact-mode fiber during the initial few laser pulses. Solid particles were reflected by the fiber tip and particles originated from failure of the fiber.http://www.dentlasertip.com